UAVs and Force: Current Debates and Future Trends in Technology, Policy and the Law

Lerner_UAVs-and-Force_PDF-imgThis study examines a representative sample of the ongoing legal and policy debates surrounding the United States’ use of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) to support or undertake lethal force abroad, particularly with respect to the surveillance and targeting of non-state asymmetric actors. The study also explores technological trends in the development of UAVs for purposes of undertaking force or force-supporting missions, as well as the trajectory of legal and policy developments in response to the use of UAVs, including possible policy consequences of further restricting the use of such platforms.

The commentary contained throughout the study is derived in part from interviews with primary sources—drawn from leading think tanks, human rights organizations, technology companies, and academia—representing a range of opinions on the technological feasibility, legality, and policy advisability of deploying UAVs for lethal force purposes. The study also draws extensively on secondary research on these same questions, from sources across the opinion spectrum.

The study finds that there are significant trends taking place in the development of UAV technology relevant to their use for intelligence-surveillance-reconnaissance (ISR) purposes in support of lethal force, and for the exercise of lethal force itself. The technology trends identified through primary source interviews and secondary source analysis include: [1] a continuing demand for, and development of, UAVs for Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance (ISR) and munitions deployment purposes; [2] the extension of the geographic range of UAVs, particularly in the context of their use aboard aircraft carriers, although obstacles may remain with respect to trade-space issues surrounding payload vs. endurance; [3] UAV designs incorporating greater levels of autonomy, requiring less direct remote piloting by humans; [4] increasing precision and maneuverability, through innovations such as smaller, lighter-weight UAVs with correspondingly smaller munitions, as well as interest in the use of directed energy as part of the UAV platform; and [5] increasing proliferation of UAV technology to both state and non-state actors, with potential for “dual-use” capabilities between ISR and weapons deployment.

Read the paper at the link below.

pdf iconBen Lerner: UAVs and Force: Current Debates and Future Trends in Technology, Policy and the Law | Center for Security Policy Occasional Paper Series | October 23, 2013 (PDF 104 pages, 2.6MB) | Executive Summary | October 23, 2013 (PDF, 6 pages, 153KB)

Lerner_UAVs and Force 10202013_NoINt

About Ben Lerner

Ben Lerner is the Vice President for Government Relations at the Center for Security Policy, where he manages the Center's educational efforts and interactions with the federal government. His articles have appeared in The American Spectator, The Washington Times, Townhall, The Washington Examiner, and inFocus Quarterly. He holds a law degree from Georgetown University, and received his bachelor's degree in political science, with highest distinction, from the University of Michigan.